|
|
File #:
|
220279
Version:
0
|
|
|
|
Type:
|
Resolution
|
Status:
|
Passed
|
|
On agenda:
|
|
Final action:
|
7/11/2022
|
|
Title:
|
Resolution relating to a Certificate of Appropriateness for the demolition of the existing parish hall, the construction of a new parish hall and the construction of a new four story apartment building at 2618 N. Hackett Ave., in the Downer Avenue Commercial Historic District, for St. Mark’s Church.
|
|
Attachments:
|
1. Application.pdf, 2. Lower Parking.JPG, 3. 1st floor Plan.JPG, 4. 2nd thru 4th floor plans.JPG, 5. Data.JPG, 6. Drawings and Summary, 7. E-mail in Opposition, 8. Opposed - Johnson, 9. Opposed - Baumes and Beckman, 10. Opposed - Herson - Updated, 11. Opposed - Herson, 12. Opposed - Espinoza and Becker, 13. 5 Opposed - Becker, Reavey, Batard, Pakroo and Kzemich, 14. Opposed - Blenski, 15. Opposed - Bultman, 16. 5 Opposed - Todorovski, McCoy, Johnson, Dunn and Parrish, 17. Opposed - Georgetown Association Board of Directors, 18. Opposed - Plotkin, 19. Opposed - Wosewick, 20. Opposed - Finch, 21. Opposed - McNamara-McGraw, 22. 2 Opposed - Sorbjan and Wosewick, 23. Opposed - Fitch, 24. Opposed - Pitt, 25. Opposed - Thompson, 26. Support - Johnston, 27. Support - Graham, 28. Support - Cope, 29. Support - Fennelly, 30. Support - Kaufmann, 31. Support - Schmidt, 32. Support - Setliff, 33. Support - McLellan, 34. 5 E-Mails in Support - Edwards, Penman, Siberio, Fricano and Farkas, 35. Support - Roloff, 36. Support - Eastside Senior Services and Kennedy, 37. Support - Downer Avenue BID, 38. Support - Loken - text, 39. Support - Loken - Screenshot, 40. Support - Barry, 41. Support - Ritchie and Hildebrand, 42. 4 Support - Zimmerman, Zimmerman, Henke and Lacy, 43. Support - Miller, 44. Support - Milwaukee Preservation Alliance, 45. Support - Falci, 46. Support - Kinship Community Food Center, 47. Support - Callanan, 48. Support - Reynolds, 49. Support-Monnat.pdf, 50. Support - Stilp, 51. Support - St. Mark's Church, 52. Support - Brostoff, 53. Support - Buckler, 54. Support - Bumburgh, 55. St. Mark's Community Meeting, 56. Street View - Late Afternoon, 57. 2nd Street View - Late Afternoon, 58. Rendering Hackett Facing North 061422.jpg, 59. Hackett Avenue Apartment Building, 60. St. Mark's Parish Hall Addition, 61. St.Mark's Alternate Basment Plan.pdf, 62. Staff Report, 63. Letter to Property Owner, 64. Letter to Property Owners Within 200 Feet, 65. List of Property Owners Within 200 Fee, 66. Certified Mailing to the Property Owner, 67. Signed Certified Mail Receipt, 68. Sign-In Sheets, 69. Certificate of Appropriateness for Demolition of Parish Hall, 70. Support - Nova Grober-Beschta, 71. AMENDED Certificate of Appropriateness, 72. Certificate of Appropriateness for Apartment Building
|
| 7/11/2022 | 0 |
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
| ADOPTED
Minutes note: Michael DeMichele - 2924 N. Shepard Ave - presenting the project
Jim Shields - architect
Ms. Carlen Hatala said there are 3 parts to this application - to demolish the parish hall, the new and smaller parish hall and a new 5-story apartment building on vacant land. It's unclear how the roof top structure is designed. Staff has recommendations in the staff report and does not object to the parish hall demolition. Staff recommends construction of a new parish hall and apartment building as they both meet the criteria for new construction. HPC only considers siting, scale, materials and form.
Supporters:
Tom Lacey - 2929 N. Shepard Ave. - member of St. Mark's parish
Brooke Frizzell - rep. of St. Mark's Church
Catherine Katter - 2231 N. 59th St. - member of St. Mark's parish
Vincent Katter - 2231 N. 59th St. - member of St. Mark's parish
John Johnson -2455 N. 58th St. - member of St. Mark's parish
Kyle Potter - 2540 N. Murray - member of St. Mark's parish
Jonathan Brostoff - 3000 N. Stowell
Sarah Marie Treed - 2706 E. Newberry Ave.
Opposed:
Deborah Bylan - 2643 N. Hackett Ave.
Philip Blenski - 2633 N. Hackett Ave.
Kay Wosewick - 2633 N. Hackett Ave.
Larraine McNamara-McGraw - 2633 N. Hackett Ave.
Grant for demolition and conceptual approval of the parish hall and approval of the COA for apartment building. Commission would like to see more detail on the parish hall and developer will work with staff on the apartment building.
Mr. Jarosz moved for demolition of the parish hall, seconded by Bauman. There were no objections.
Mr. Jarosz moved for approval of the apartment with follow-up to work with staff, seconded by Bauman. There were no objections.
Mr. Jarosz moved for more details on the new parish hall and that will be scheduled as a separate item. Seconded by Bauman. There were no objections.
| Pass | 5:0 |
Action details
|
Meeting details
|
Video
|
| 6/15/2022 | 0 |
COMMON COUNCIL
| ASSIGNED TO | | |
Action details
|
Meeting details
|
Not available
|
|
Number
220279
Version
ORIGINAL
Reference
Sponsor
THE CHAIR
Title
Resolution relating to a Certificate of Appropriateness for the demolition of the existing parish hall, the construction of a new parish hall and the construction of a new four story apartment building at 2618 N. Hackett Ave., in the Downer Avenue Commercial Historic District, for St. Mark’s Church.
Drafter
CC-CC
Carlen Hatala
6/14/2022
|