From: Mellisa Johnson Sent: Wednesday, June 22, 2022 11:31 AM To: Owczarski, Jim; Elmer, Linda Subject: Letter of objection Some people who received this message don't often get email from mljohnson778@gmail.com. Learn why this is important 06/22/2022 Ms. Elmer; I am writing in opposition to proposed changes of the Downer Avenue Commercial Historic District. After attending the meeting and reviewing the plans that were supplied and researching the historical guidelines I believe that the proposed changes go against the guidelines of the Historic Preservation Commission set out in the Final Historical Designation Study Report for North Downer Avenue Commercial District. Under Section H of the Preservation Guidelines it states that “new construction should be as sympathetic as possible with the character of the district.” The exterior designs that have been published do not match the character of the district. Section H Subsection 1 states “New construction must respect the historic sitting of the district.” There should be cohesiveness of the district. I would again argue that the proposed apartment complex and proposed addition to St. Marks look more like a modern development added into a historic neighborhood. Section H Subsection 2 refers to the scale of a building and that new construction height must be compatible with historic buildings in the area. I believe this is another area where the proposed project fails to meet the guidelines of the historic district. Lastly, Section H Subsection 3 refers to Form and that “The massing of new construction must be compatible with the goal of maintaining the integrity of the complex as a cohesive group of historic structures.” All of these points are part of the guidelines set out in the designation study by the Historic Preservation Commission and should be followed to maintain the integrity of the Downer Avenue Commercial Historic District. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Mellisa Johnson 2645 N Summit Ave Milwaukee, WI 53211