powered help
header-left header-center header-right
Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Bookmark and Share
File #: 191145    Version: 0
Type: Resolution Status: Placed On File
File created: 10/29/2019 In control: HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
On agenda: Final action: 12/10/2019
Effective date:    
Title: Resolution relating to the Permanent Historic Designation of the Garner-Ranney-Schutz House at 1247 N. Milwaukee Street in the 4th Ald. District.
Sponsors: THE CHAIR
Attachments: 1. Permanent Designation Application.pdf, 2. Cover, 3. Report, 4. E-Mail in Support of the Designation, 5. E-Mail in Opposition to the Designation by Peter Feigin, 6. Response of Ald Bauman re Peter Feigin e-mail, 7. E-Mails between Ald Bauman and Peter Feigin, 8. Letter to Property Owner, 9. Letter to the Nominator, 10. Letter to Property Owners Within 200 Feet, 11. LIst of Property Owners Within 200 Feet, 12. Certified Mailing to the Nominator, 13. Certified Mailing to the Property Owner, 14. Signed Certified Mail Receipt, 15. Signed Certified Mail Receipt - JustABuck, LLC, 16. Signed Certified Mail Receipt, 17. Withdrawal of the Nomination, 18. Sign-In Sheets, 19. Refused - Unable to Forward Mailing, 20. Signed Certified Mail Receipt, 21. Plats and Parcels_ Downtown House Being Deconstructed For Apartments ยป Urban Milwaukee.pdf
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultTallyAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
12/9/20190 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION RECOMMENDED FOR PLACING ON FILE

Minutes note: Ms. Carlen Hatala said Ms. McCarthy applied for temporary designation to start the process for permanent designation, which held off on the requested demolition permit. The house was in existance in 1872 and most of the structures during that time have been demolished and replaced. The house was in existance as early as 1865, and possibly earlier. There were a number of families who lived in the house over the years, one for a period of 33 years. Stucco cladding was added in 1910 was a result of remodeling. Theodore Schutz, the architect, was the building's longest owner. Ms. Hatala listed properties that had been remodeled, but were still designated as historic. Dr. Garner, who owned the house at one time, was a prominent physician, who had trainng on the east coast. Theodore Schutz altered the house beginning in 1892. The foundation is all original to the house. A lot of the building features aren't original, but are reversible on the porch. In 11904, the roof was raised and it was converted to a duplex in 1918. Mr. Schutz worked as an independent architect and designed a number of buildings still standing on Brady Street. Ms. Hatala recommends approval of the historic designation based on the building meeting e-1, e-3, e-6 and e-9 sections of the code. Mr. Jarosz moved, seconded by Ald. Bauman to open the matter for a public hearing. There were no objections. Opposed: Peter Feigin - did not wish to speak John Vogel - historian who feels that preservation and progress must be balanced. He disagrees that this house meets the criteria for designation. Pat Connaughton - plan to deconstruct and put in a few units. They will be doing deconstruction, not demolition. Atty. Bruce Block - he is not here representing Mr. Connaught. His practice is commercial real estate and he is very involved with historic preservation and has been for over 20 years. He does not think this building meets the standards of the ordinance. Supporters: Gail Fitch - 1733 N. Cambridge Ave. - has written historic articles over a number of years. She wondered if the house could be moved. Dawn McCarthy - nominator - 2589 N. Lake Dr. - she agrees with staff that the house meets the four criteria outlined by Ms. Hatala. Mr. Jarosz moved, seconded by Ms. Pieper Eisenbrown, to close the public hearing. There were no objections. Mr. Jarosz said that he doesn't support nomination as the building doesn't rise up to the nomination. The other three commissioners concurred.
Pass4:0 Action details Meeting details Video Video
10/29/20190 COMMON COUNCIL ASSIGNED TO   Action details Meeting details Not available

Number

191145

 

Version

ORIGINAL

 

Reference

191144

 

Sponsor

THE CHAIR

 

Title

Resolution relating to the Permanent Historic Designation of the Garner-Ranney-Schutz House at 1247 N. Milwaukee Street in the 4th Ald. District.

Drafter

CC-CC

Tim Askin

10/29/19