powered help
header-left header-center header-right
Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Bookmark and Share
File #: 181795    Version: 0
Type: Resolution Status: Passed
File created: 3/6/2019 In control: HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
On agenda: Final action: 4/1/2019
Effective date:    
Title: Resolution relating to a Certificate of Appropriateness for a rooftop addition and other modifications for converting to residential use, the property at 1945 N. Bartlett Avenue, the Milwaukee Fire Department’s Firehouse Ladder Company No. 5, an individually designated historic property, for Lincoln and Lilith Fowler.
Sponsors: THE CHAIR
Attachments: 1. Application.pdf, 2. Marvin Windows - shop drawings.pdf, 3. Drawing 1, 4. Drawing 2, 5. Drawing 3, 6. Drawing 4, 7. Drawing 5, 8. Drawing 6, 9. DSC01447, 10. DSC01449, 11. Exterior Photos attachments 11-162 IMG_0208, 12. IMG_0209, 13. IMG_0210, 14. IMG_0211, 15. IMG_0212, 16. IMG_0213, 17. IMG_0214, 18. IMG_0215, 19. IMG_0216, 20. IMG_0217, 21. IMG_0218, 22. IMG_0219, 23. IMG_0220, 24. IMG_0221, 25. IMG_0222, 26. IMG_0223, 27. IMG_0224, 28. IMG_0225, 29. IMG_0226, 30. IMG_0227, 31. IMG_0228, 32. IMG_0229, 33. IMG_0230, 34. IMG_0231, 35. IMG_0232, 36. IMG_0233, 37. IMG_0234, 38. IMG_0235, 39. IMG_0236, 40. IMG_0237, 41. IMG_0238, 42. IMG_0239, 43. IMG_0240, 44. IMG_0241, 45. IMG_0242, 46. IMG_0243, 47. IMG_0244, 48. IMG_0245, 49. IMG_0246, 50. IMG_0247, 51. IMG_0248, 52. IMG_0249, 53. IMG_0250, 54. IMG_0251, 55. IMG_0252, 56. IMG_0346, 57. IMG_0347, 58. IMG_0348, 59. IMG_0349, 60. IMG_0350, 61. IMG_0351, 62. IMG_0352, 63. IMG_0353, 64. IMG_0354, 65. IMG_0355, 66. IMG_0356, 67. IMG_0357, 68. IMG_0358, 69. IMG_0359, 70. IMG_0360, 71. IMG_0361, 72. IMG_0362, 73. IMG_0363, 74. IMG_0364, 75. IMG_0365, 76. IMG_0366, 77. IMG_0367, 78. IMG_0368, 79. IMG_0369, 80. IMG_0370, 81. IMG_0371, 82. IMG_0372, 83. IMG_0373, 84. IMG_0374, 85. IMG_0375, 86. IMG_0376, 87. IMG_0377, 88. IMG_0378, 89. IMG_0379, 90. IMG_0380, 91. IMG_0381, 92. IMG_0382, 93. IMG_0383, 94. IMG_0384, 95. IMG_0385, 96. IMG_0386, 97. IMG_0387, 98. IMG_0388, 99. IMG_0389, 100. IMG_0390, 101. IMG_0391, 102. IMG_0392, 103. IMG_0393, 104. IMG_0394, 105. IMG_0395, 106. IMG_0396, 107. IMG_0397, 108. IMG_0398, 109. IMG_0399, 110. IMG_0400, 111. IMG_0401, 112. IMG_0402, 113. IMG_0403, 114. IMG_0404, 115. IMG_0405, 116. IMG_0406, 117. IMG_0420, 118. IMG_0421, 119. IMG_0422, 120. IMG_0423, 121. IMG_0424, 122. IMG_0425, 123. IMG_0426, 124. IMG_0427, 125. IMG_0428, 126. IMG_0429, 127. IMG_0430, 128. IMG_0431, 129. IMG_0432, 130. IMG_0433, 131. IMG_0434, 132. IMG_0435, 133. IMG_0436, 134. IMG_0437, 135. IMG_0438, 136. IMG_0439, 137. IMG_0440, 138. IMG_0441, 139. IMG_0442, 140. IMG_0443, 141. IMG_0444, 142. IMG_0445, 143. IMG_0446, 144. IMG_0447, 145. IMG_0448, 146. IMG_0449, 147. IMG_0450, 148. IMG_0451, 149. IMG_0452, 150. IMG_0453, 151. IMG_0454, 152. IMG_0455, 153. IMG_0456, 154. IMG_0457, 155. IMG_0458, 156. IMG_0459, 157. IMG_0460, 158. IMG_0461, 159. IMG_0462, 160. IMG_0463, 161. IMG_0464, 162. IMG_3797, 163. Interior Photos Attachments 163-264 IMG_0253, 164. IMG_0254, 165. IMG_0255, 166. IMG_0256, 167. IMG_0257, 168. IMG_0258, 169. IMG_0259, 170. IMG_0261, 171. IMG_0262, 172. IMG_0263, 173. IMG_0264, 174. IMG_0265, 175. IMG_0267, 176. IMG_0268, 177. IMG_0269, 178. IMG_0270, 179. IMG_0271, 180. IMG_0272, 181. IMG_0273, 182. IMG_0274, 183. IMG_0275, 184. IMG_0276, 185. IMG_0278, 186. IMG_0279, 187. IMG_0280, 188. IMG_0281, 189. IMG_0282, 190. IMG_0283, 191. IMG_0284, 192. IMG_0285, 193. IMG_0286, 194. IMG_0287, 195. IMG_0288, 196. IMG_0289, 197. IMG_0290, 198. IMG_0291, 199. IMG_0292, 200. IMG_0293, 201. IMG_0294, 202. IMG_0295, 203. IMG_0296, 204. IMG_0297, 205. IMG_0298, 206. IMG_0300, 207. IMG_0301, 208. IMG_0302, 209. IMG_0303, 210. IMG_0304, 211. IMG_0305, 212. IMG_0306, 213. IMG_0307, 214. IMG_0308, 215. IMG_0309, 216. IMG_0310, 217. IMG_0311, 218. IMG_0312, 219. IMG_0313, 220. IMG_0314, 221. IMG_0315, 222. IMG_0316, 223. IMG_0317, 224. IMG_0318, 225. IMG_0319, 226. IMG_0320, 227. IMG_0321, 228. IMG_0322, 229. IMG_0323, 230. IMG_0324, 231. IMG_0325, 232. IMG_0326, 233. IMG_0327, 234. IMG_0328, 235. IMG_0329, 236. IMG_0330, 237. IMG_0331, 238. IMG_0332, 239. IMG_0333, 240. IMG_0334, 241. IMG_0335, 242. IMG_0336, 243. IMG_0337, 244. IMG_0338, 245. IMG_0339, 246. IMG_0340, 247. IMG_0341, 248. IMG_0342, 249. IMG_0343, 250. IMG_0344, 251. IMG_0345, 252. IMG_0407, 253. IMG_0408, 254. IMG_0409, 255. IMG_0410, 256. IMG_0411, 257. IMG_0412, 258. IMG_0413, 259. IMG_0414, 260. IMG_0415, 261. IMG_0416, 262. IMG_0417, 263. IMG_0418, 264. IMG_0419, 265. Option A Rendering 1, 266. Option A Rendering 2, 267. Option A Rendering 3, 268. Option A Rendering, 269. Option A Rendering 5, 270. Option A Rendering 6, 271. Option A Rendering 7, 272. Option B Rendering 1, 273. Option B Rendering 2, 274. Option B Rendering 3, 275. Option B Rendering 4, 276. Option B Rendering 5, 277. Option B Rendering 6, 278. Option B Rendering 7, 279. A300.pdf, 280. A301.pdf, 281. Revised Renderings 3-18-19, 282. Staff Report, 283. PowerPoint, 284. Letter to the Local Council Member, 285. Letter to Property Owner, 286. Letter to Property Owners Within 200 Feet, 287. List of Property Owners Within 200 Feet, 288. Certified Mailing to the Property Owner, 289. Certified Mail Receipt, 290. Signed Certified Mail Receipt, 291. Final Plan Set T100.jpg, 292. Final Plan Set D101.jpg, 293. Final Plan Set D102.jpg, 294. Final Plan Set A001.jpg, 295. Final Plan Set A102.jpg, 296. Final Plan Set A002.jpg, 297. Final Plan Set A101.jpg, 298. Final Plan Set A103.jpg, 299. Final Plan Set A111.jpg, 300. Final Plan Set A112.jpg, 301. Final Plan Set A201.jpg, 302. Final Plan Set A202.jpg, 303. Final Plan Set A203.jpg, 304. Final Plan Set A301.jpg, 305. Final Plan Set A302.jpg, 306. Final Plan Set A501.jpg, 307. Final Plan Set S0.1.jpg, 308. Final Plan Set S1.0.jpg, 309. Final Plan Set S2.0.jpg, 310. Final Plan Set S3.0.jpg, 311. Final Plan Set S4.0.jpg, 312. Final Plan Set S4.1.jpg, 313. Certificate of Appropriateness
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultTallyAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
4/1/20190 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION  

Minutes note: Mr Tim Askin said the intern helped a lot with this report. These are new owners and new architects. The applicant is proposing to replace all the windows as they are not savable and are proposing Marvin Ultimate double-hung with most of the windows. The plan is to switch the door and window in front so they are reversed. There will be three new windows on the street side. A new rooftop addition is being proposed which would be slightly lower than a full floor, with a deck and penthouse. Exterior mechanicals will be on the roof and not street-visible. Staff has a lot of conditions. Lilith and Lincoln Fowler - 2969 N. Mariettta - they have been thinking about this building for 20 years. The primary issue is light and interior design has been based on maximizing natural light. Staff recommends approval with conditions, striking conditions 3 and 5. The fence will be refined with what the owners want to do (and not visible from the street). The windows on the south elevation being aluminum clad are fine with the Commission. Other windows (including a new one on the 2nd floor) will be wood. Mr. Jarosz thinks the design is good and pretty sensitive. Applicant does not object to the remaining conditions.
   Not available Meeting details Video Video

Number

Version

ORIGINAL

Reference

 

Sponsor

THE CHAIR

Title

Resolution relating to a Certificate of Appropriateness for a rooftop addition and other modifications for converting to residential use, the property at 1945 N. Bartlett Avenue, the Milwaukee Fire Department’s Firehouse Ladder Company No. 5, an individually designated historic property, for Lincoln and Lilith Fowler.

Drafter

CC-CC

Tim Askin

3/6/19