|
|
File #:
|
170674
Version:
0
|
|
|
|
Type:
|
Resolution
|
Status:
|
Passed
|
|
On agenda:
|
|
Final action:
|
9/11/2017
|
|
Title:
|
Resolution relating to a Certificate of Appropriateness for the modifications required to convert to residential use the property at 1945 N. Bartlett Avenue, the Milwaukee Fire Department’s Firehouse Ladder Company No. 5, an individually designated historic property, for Jalem Getz.
|
|
Attachments:
|
1. Application.pdf, 2. Objections from a Neighbor, 3. 01 LADDER CO#5 - AS.01 ARCHITECTURAL SITE PLAN.PDF, 4. 02 LADDER CO#5 - A1.01 PROPOSED GROUND FLOOR & BASEMENT PLAN.PDF, 5. 04 LADDER CO#5 - A4.00 PROPOSED ARCHITECTURAL RENDERINGS.PDF, 6. 05 LADDER CO#5 - A4.01 PROPOSED EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS.PDF, 7. 07 LADDER CO#5 - A4.02 PROPOSED EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS.PDF, 8. Archive pictures 1.pdf, 9. Archive pictures 2.pdf, 10. Bartlett Avenue Rendering_D.jpg, 11. Irving Place Rendering_D.jpg, 12. 03 LADDER CO#5 - A1.02 PROPOSED 2ND FLOOR AND ROOF PLAN.PDF, 13. Response to Staff Questions, 14. Rooftop Addition Cladding Sample Photograph.jpg, 15. Rooftop Addition Cladding Specs.pdf, 16. Bartlett Elevation (1).JPG, 17. Bartlett Elevation (2).JPG, 18. Bartlett Elevation (3).JPG, 19. Bartlett Elevation (4).JPG, 20. Bartlett Elevation (5).JPG, 21. Bartlett Elevation (6).JPG, 22. Bartlett Service Door (2).JPG, 23. Hayloft Doors (1).JPG, 24. Bartlett Service Door (2).JPG, 25. Bartlett Service Door (3).JPG, 26. Irving Elevation (1).JPG, 27. Irving Elevation (2).JPG, 28. Irving Elevation (3).JPG, 29. Irving Planting Area.JPG, 30. Stair-Elevator Tower Detail.JPG, 31. Rear Elevation (3).JPG, 32. Rear Elevation (4).JPG, 33. Rear Elevation (1).JPG, 34. South Elevation (1).JPG, 35. Staff Report, 36. Revised East and North Elevations, 37. Revised West and South Elevations, 38. Letter to the Local Council Member, 39. Letter to Property Owner, 40. Letter to Property Owners Within 200 Feet, 41. List of Property Owners Within 200 Feet, 42. Certificate of Appropriateness
|
| 9/11/2017 | 0 |
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
| ADOPTED
Minutes note: Mr. Tim Askin said that is being proposed for residential use. It was abandoned as a firehouse in 1914 and has no plumbing. It was used as long-term storage for over 90 years. There is no sewer access provided for at the property. The project is not eligible for tax credits so it will face no other political review. Staff does not support deep masonry cleaning or the addition of a penthouse. The owner is proposing to add/retain historic elements. The owner is proposing adding 900 square feet on top of the building. They are removing the elevator and putting in a staircase in that space. Staff also objects to proposed cladding - would prefer "Pre patina" from the same manufacturer, rather than "Natural". Staff also recommends clipping or rounding one corner to reduce visibility. Staff can accept the proposed door submitted on Friday. There are 2 balconies projected, with one being a French balcony. Staff does not support the proposed changes to the hayloft doors on the second floor. Staff recommends no cleaning of the south elevation go past the chimney line as it can't be seen by the general public anyway. Staff recommends approval with 13 conditions detailed in its staff report.
Jalem Getz - propery owner - his mother will live on the lower level and his family on the second floor and above. This is his pet project for him. He worked very closely with staff as did his architect.
Ald. Bauman likes the square of the roof as it provides symmetry with the square-cornered building.
The owner will accept all the staff recommendations except #1 and #2.
Approval with all staff recommendations, except #1 and #2. | Pass | 4:0 |
Action details
|
Meeting details
|
Video
|
|
Number
Version
ORIGINAL
Reference
Sponsor
THE CHAIR
Title
Resolution relating to a Certificate of Appropriateness for the modifications required to convert to residential use the property at 1945 N. Bartlett Avenue, the Milwaukee Fire Department’s Firehouse Ladder Company No. 5, an individually designated historic property, for Jalem Getz.
Drafter
CC-CC
Tim Askin
8/14/17
|