| 10/10/2022 | 0 |
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
| ADOPTED
Minutes note: Ms. Hatala provided an e-mail from Mr. Jarosz, who investigated the roof. He concurs that the roof is not repairable. An asphalt roof is $55,000 vs. $85,000 for a clay tile roof.
Arthur Asha - can't afford $55,000. He got a different quote in the $20,000's.
Mr. Jarosz recommended getting more than one quote for someone putting on an asphalt roof. Mr. Asha believes Brava meets all specifications for Wisconsin weather and is a lighter material, which is better for the house. He can best afford asphalt.
The Commission would like to see one more quote using approved materials by the HPC.
Mr. Hans Robinson suggested a synthetic material and look for a subsidy to bridge the finances.
Mr. Ashe said the tax credits won't make that much of a difference.
Moved for approval of asphalt with the color and product and with the work done by a reputable contractor approved by staff. | Pass | 5:0 |
Action details
|
Meeting details
|
Video
|
| 9/12/2022 | 0 |
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
| HELD IN COMMITTEE
Minutes note: Ms. Hatala said the estimated cost from Dave North was for $160,000 and he got a verbal estimate of $200,000 from another contractor and an estimate of $98,000 from Community Roofing. Ken Langer provided an estimate of $2,900 per day to make repairs and a additional cost for snowguards ($10,000). Dave North said the roof was unrepairable, while Langer said they could do repairs.
The owner would like a red roof, so options are limited.
With the cost estimates, Mr. Askin would lean towards the Brava (which is a composite). Work would probably be done in the spring, although the roofer said they could expedite it.
Hold off until next month as Mr. Jarosz will contact the state about the acceptability of a composite roof and potential snowball effect if this is approved. He would also like to see photos of the roof deterioration.
| Pass | 6:0 |
Action details
|
Meeting details
|
Video
|
| 8/1/2022 | 0 |
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
| HELD IN COMMITTEE
Minutes note: Ms. Carlen Hatala said the applicant has a red tile roof on the house built in the late 1930s. The garage also has a tile roof. The applicant has looked into asphalt shingles. There are plastic tiles, concrete tiles and clay tiles. There are also metal tiles that are formed to look like Spanish tiles. If the tiles are outside of the cost of his budget, staff would recommend asphalt shingles as a last resort.
Andre Ash - 3357 N. Sherman Blvd. - a rough estimate for clay tile is $160,000. The roof is in total disrepair with falling tiles and pieces of tiles. An asphalt roof would cost $20,000.
Patrick Fay - roofing contractor - 95% of the other roofs are asphalt. A similar roof would be $50,000, which is 1/3 of the house's value.
Mr. Jarosz would like to see some bids prior to making a decision.
Mr. Jarosz would like to schedule this next month to get additional bids.
| Pass | 6:0 |
Action details
|
Meeting details
|
Video
|